Milk of Madagascar

by Omnom
Info Details
Country Iceland   
Type Milk Chocolate   (41%; Batch 057)
Strain Blend   
Source Madagascar   (Ambanja)
Flavor Earthen   
Style Mainstream      
REDUX REVIEW: 2 bars... same origin / percentage / formulation; one released in 2014, & the other in 2017
M.O.M. meet M.O.M.: Milk of Magnesia® meets its match in this Milk of Madagascar.

Both serve as gentle laxatives (cacáo particularly fulfilled this function, among several others, in pre-Columbian times).

This bar proves far tastier -- if somewhat less efficacious in its reaction -- than the modern Phillips product.
Appearance   4.6 / 5
Color: so Nordic... the pink silt of a tanned blonde
Surface: what once showed voids the size of reptiles' eyes now seals prefectly
Temper: glassy
Snap: sharp hollows
Aroma   6.9 / 10
utterly un-resplendent
frozen milk basically
blank, save for faint bacon suet
let sit & it opens only to various green leaves + brucite

a milk stud
Mouthfeel   11.7 / 15
Texture: 2014: fine grain
2017: stiff
Melt: verklumped
Flavor   45 / 50
candy corn swishing around caramel -> casein struggles to gain a purchase… rebuffed happily by saline solution & umami points -> cereal (corn, again, but now just the starch minus the sweetener) -> cocoa malt

milk-malt -> those candy corn FXs of yore still present -> dairy proteins weigh heavily on the tail -> back hay
Quality   16.4 / 20
In a field now studded with several outstanding Milks & Dark-Milks of Madagascar cocoa, this is not one of them. At least not in the expected sense.

Texture well off world-class standards notwithstanding 72 hours in the conche (undoubtedly low & slow). Plus a curious Madagascar by Omnom to go with its mid-weight 66%.

No real indicator of Madagascan cacáo with its usual fruit-laden acidity in this bar. For instance, the promised red berries never manifest here like they do in abundance in Omnom's Semi-Dark version.

For that berry blush to surface in a Milk Chocolate configuration requires a different formulation of more than 41% (deceiving since the overwhelming majority comprises fat as opposed to mass, as sniffed out in the Aroma) &/or a re-calibrated roast / processing (which burns off some substantial volatiles).

Very respectable though, such as it is, a rather conventional Milk Choc but more streamlined & fine in its exposition. Credit Omnom's election to go without vanilla which lightens the load on the palate considerably.

It'd be flip & misguided to think that just about any cocoa origin could achieve the same. Madagascar, after all, cultivates a buoyant cocoa that rarely plods up the works into a ponderous sludge that some others, if mishandled, certainly would (West Africa, for example).

Despite sub-optimal utilization of this island's cacáo, Omnom still pulls off a treasurable payload.

Conceptual & technical questions aside, a real joy-maker & better than its overall rating which suffers some because of ancillaries (Aroma & Texture).

INGREDIENTS: sugar, cocoa butter, cocoa mass

Reviewed April 29, 2014
Revised July 6, 2017


Signup for our free Newsletter

Signup for our free Newsletter

Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from the C-spot.

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Pin It on Pinterest